How to Ask for a Counteroffer When You Have Another Job Offer: Steps (With Scripts)

Use this when a written outside offer is already in hand and you would rather stay — how to time the ask, price it, and get it in writing.

By Theo Lindqvist · Published · Updated · 13 min read

Featured image for "How to Ask for a Counteroffer When You Have Another Job Offer: Steps (With Scripts)"

Asking your current employer to counter an outside offer works best when you have a written offer in hand, a number you can justify, and a genuine willingness to stay if they meet it. The ask itself is short: a live conversation with your manager, a specific figure, a short list of what else would need to change, and a written confirmation before you turn anything down.

This guide covers when to raise it, the steps and lead times, what to say word for word, the mistakes that cost people both jobs, and what to do if the answer is no.

When to do it, and when to wait

Raise a counteroffer request when all of these are true at once — a written offer, a real willingness to stay, and someone to ask. Any one of them missing turns the conversation into a bluff you can't back.

  • You have the outside offer in writing, with a decision date. A verbal "we'd like to bring you on" is not leverage. Wait for the written offer letter with base pay, start date, and benefits. CareerOneStop advises taking time to consider any offer and asking for at least 24 hours to decide, which is usually enough space to open the conversation at your current job.
  • You can name exactly what would make you stay. Pay is only one lever. The Work Institute's 2020 Retention Report, cited by SHRM, analysed over 233,000 employees from 2010 to 2019 and found one in five people who moved to a different employer in 2019 did so over career-development concerns. If scope, title, or a path to the next role is the real issue, money alone won't fix it — and a counteroffer that ignores it won't hold.
  • Someone in the chain can actually move the number. Ask yourself who signs off: your manager, their director, or an HR compensation team working from a fixed band. Smaller organisations tend to move faster — the hiring-manager survey reported by SHRM in 2020 found companies with fewer than 50 employees are more likely to make counteroffers.
  • Your own market research supports the figure. Glassdoor notes that a well-prepared case built on market data and documented contributions can be as effective as waving a competing offer. Check published wage data for your occupation and area — the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook and your state labor department are starting points, and pay varies widely by employer, state, and country.
  • A budget or review cycle is close. If headcount budgets reset next month, saying so gives your manager a route to approval instead of an exception.

Not yet: if you already know you're leaving regardless of the money, don't ask. A counteroffer request signals you'll stay if matched. If you take the raise and leave anyway, you've spent a reference. And if you've only had a strong interview rather than a signed offer, wait — CareerOneStop's guidance is to hold salary conversations until there's an actual offer on the table.

Step by step

  1. Get the outside offer in writing and buy time. Email the recruiter and ask for the full written offer — base, bonus structure, equity if any, benefits, start date. Then request a decision window. CareerOneStop suggests asking for at least 24 hours; in practice most employers grant two to five business days, longer if a background check or references are still pending. Lead time: same day to 48 hours.
  2. Price both packages side by side. Build a simple spreadsheet with base pay, any bonus, employer retirement contribution, health premium cost to you, paid leave, and commuting or relocation costs. CareerOneStop advises weighing base salary and benefits together to see longer-term potential. A higher base can lose to a better retirement match. Lead time: one to two hours.
  3. Research the market band for the role. Pull the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook entry for your occupation, your state labor department's wage data, and any salary survey your professional association publishes to members. Note that these are area and occupation averages, not your employer's band. Lead time: an afternoon.
  4. Set one number and three non-pay conditions. Glassdoor describes a counter of 10% to 20% above the initial figure as generally reasonable depending on market research, with anything higher needing strong justification — the same logic applies to what you ask your current employer for. Write down the number, the floor you'd actually accept, and the three non-pay changes (scope, title, reporting line, remote days, training budget) that would make staying worth it. Lead time: 30 minutes, after step 3.
  5. Write a one-page contribution summary. List three to five things you delivered in the last 12 months with a date, a number if you have one, and who benefited. This is the document you reference in the meeting and attach to the follow-up email. Lead time: one to two hours.
  6. Book a live conversation with your manager. Ask for 20 to 30 minutes, same week, described as "a conversation about my role and compensation" — not a surprise. Glassdoor notes that phone or video allows real-time dialogue and tone, while email suits follow-ups and a written record; many people open live and confirm in writing afterwards. Lead time: one to three days to get calendar time.
  7. Make the ask once, then stop talking. State the situation, the number, and the conditions. Indeed's guidance is to counter once or twice at most and not to reopen a package already agreed. Give your manager the deadline from the outside offer so they know what they're working against. Lead time: the meeting itself.
  8. Get the counter in writing before you decline anything. Ask for an amended offer letter or an email from HR stating the new base, effective date, and any agreed change to title or scope. Approval chains take two days in a small firm and two to three weeks where a compensation committee or a public-sector pay scale is involved. If your contract has notice or non-compete clauses you don't understand, speak to an employment attorney in your state — don't rely on your manager's summary. Lead time: two days to three weeks.

What to say

Open live, keep it short, and let the silence after your number do some work. Then confirm in writing the same day.

Spoken opener — manager, in person or on video

"Thanks for making time. I want to be straightforward with you. I wasn't actively looking, but I've been approached and I now have a written offer from another company. The base is [$X], which is [N]% above what I'm on, and the role covers [scope or responsibility].

I'd rather stay. The work on [project] matters to me and I'd like to see [outcome] through. What would make staying the clear choice is [$Y] base, plus [non-pay condition, e.g. ownership of the [area] workstream and a decision on the [title] step by [month]].

I need to respond to them by [date]. I know that's tight — what's realistic from your side in that window?"

If your manager asks whether you'd stay for less

"I'd want to be honest rather than haggle. [$Y] is where the two options become comparable to me once I account for [benefit or cost difference]. If the band won't stretch that far, tell me what the ceiling is and what else you could move on — [extra leave / training budget / the title change / the [area] remit] — and I'll weigh the whole package."

If you want more time

"I'll ask them for an extra [two to three] business days so you can get the right approvals. If I can tell them I'm waiting on a formal response from you by [date], that usually buys the room."

Follow-up email, same day

Subject: Follow-up on our conversation — [your name]

Hi [manager],

Thanks for the conversation today. To put it in writing so you have something to take to [HR / [director]]:

- I have a written offer from another employer with a response deadline of [date]. - I would prefer to stay at [company]. - What would make that straightforward: base of [$Y], effective [date], plus [non-pay condition] and [non-pay condition].

I've attached a one-page summary of what I've delivered this year, including [project] and [project], in case it's useful for the approval.

Happy to answer anything, and I'll hold off on responding to them until [date].

[Your name]

Email to the outside employer, asking for a few more days

Subject: [Role] offer — timing

Hi [recruiter],

Thank you again for the offer. I'm taking it seriously and working through the details. Could I have until [date] to give you a firm answer? That's [N] business days past the original deadline.

If that doesn't work on your side, let me know what is workable and I'll plan around it.

[Your name]

Accepting the counter

"That works for me. Can you send the amended terms in writing — base, effective date, and the change to [scope or title] — and I'll decline the other offer as soon as it lands. I'd also like to put [date] in the diary to review how the [area] remit is going."

Mistakes to avoid

MistakeWhy it backfires
Bluffing about an offer you don't haveIf your manager asks for the written offer or a start date, or mentions it to someone who knows the other company, you have nothing. Even unproven, the suspicion follows you into the next performance cycle.
Issuing an ultimatumGlassdoor notes that a reasonable counter rarely results in a withdrawn offer, with the exceptions being demands far above the role's budget or an ultimatum that signals inflexibility. "Match it or I leave Friday" removes your manager's room to advocate for you.
Negotiating three and four timesIndeed's guidance is to counter once or twice at most and not to reopen a package already agreed. Each extra round reads as moving goalposts and spends the goodwill you need afterwards.
Asking for money when the problem isn't moneyIf the real issue is your manager, your scope, or no visible next step, a higher base changes nothing by month three. The Work Institute data cited by SHRM found career development drove one in five moves in 2019.
Accepting a verbal promise"We'll sort you out at the next review" is not a counteroffer. Reorganisations, budget freezes and manager changes erase it. Nothing counts until it's in an amended letter or an email from HR with an effective date.
Ignoring what happens to people who acceptThe evidence is genuinely mixed and worth facing. The hiring-manager survey reported by SHRM in 2020 found 65% of employees who accept a counteroffer stay at least another two years, and that employees reject counteroffers 35% of the time. An independent Robert Half survey of Australian business leaders found the opposite pattern: 52% of employees who accepted a counteroffer left within a year, and 19% within six months. Ask yourself which picture your own reasons for looking resemble.

If the answer is no

A no is useful information, delivered free. Work through it on a schedule rather than reacting in the meeting.

In the meeting (same day): thank them and ask two questions — what the top of the band is for your role, and what would have to change for you to reach it. Write the answers down verbatim. Don't announce a decision while you're annoyed.

Within 24 hours: re-read the outside offer against your spreadsheet from step 2, benefits included. Ask the outside employer any open question — start date flexibility, review timing, remote days. If you need one more day to decide, ask once and give a date.

Within 2 to 5 business days: decide and tell both sides. If you're going, accept in writing first, then resign in writing, then tell your manager verbally the same day. Check your contract for the notice period and your handbook for anything on unused leave; notice and final-pay rules vary by employer, state and country, so ask an employment attorney if the contract is unclear.

Weeks 1 to 2 of notice: write a handover document for [project] — status, contacts, passwords routed through IT, open decisions. Ask two colleagues for a reference or a written recommendation while the work is fresh.

If you stay anyway, because the outside offer wasn't right: put a date in your calendar 60 to 90 days out and tell your manager you'd like a structured conversation then about the band ceiling they named. Keep a running log of delivered work. Glassdoor notes a prepared case built on market data and documented contributions can be as effective as a competing offer — you'll want it ready.

At 3 to 6 months: reassess honestly. If nothing moved on the band, the scope or the development path after a documented request, you now have evidence rather than a feeling, and your next search starts from a stronger position.

Frequently asked questions

How much more should I ask for?

Anchor on the outside offer and on market data, not on a round number. Glassdoor describes a counter of 10% to 20% above an initial figure as generally reasonable depending on research into the market rate, with more than that requiring strong justification. Check the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook and your state labor department for occupation and area wage data, and your professional association if it surveys members — then adjust for employer size, sector and location, which drive most of the spread. Weigh base and benefits together, as CareerOneStop advises, so you're comparing packages rather than headline numbers.

When in the process should I tell my current employer?

After the outside offer is in writing and before you've accepted it. Too early and you have nothing concrete; too late and you've already given your word to someone else. Ask the outside employer for a decision window first — CareerOneStop suggests requesting at least 24 hours on any offer, and many employers will extend to several business days. Then give your manager the deadline, so the approval chain has something to work to.

Should I have the conversation by phone, video or email?

Start live and confirm in writing. Glassdoor notes that phone or video calls allow real-time dialogue and tone, while email works well for follow-ups or when you want a written record — and that many negotiators do both, opening live and confirming details afterwards. Send the summary email the same day so your manager can forward it to HR without re-typing your ask.

How do I follow up if nobody gets back to me?

Send one short email 48 hours after the conversation restating the deadline and asking for a yes or no by a specific date. If approvals sit with a compensation team or a public-sector pay scale, two to three weeks is normal, so ask the outside employer for an extension rather than chasing daily. One follow-up, then a decision — Indeed's guidance is to counter once or twice at most, and the same restraint applies to chasing.

Is it worse to counter at a new employer than at my current one?

Candidates tend to overestimate the risk. Researchers found managers withdraw offers after a counter far less often than candidates believe, per a 2024 study in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes cited by Glassdoor, and a reasonable counter rarely results in a withdrawn offer — the exceptions being demands far above the role's budget or an ultimatum. The caution is in how you ask, not whether you ask.

Sources

  1. CareerOneStop — Negotiate your salary
  2. CareerOneStop — Negotiate an offer

Written by

Theo Lindqvist

Theo tracks hiring trends, wage shifts, and the quiet negotiations happening inside job postings. He reads want ads the way other people read tea leaves.

More in Industry-Specific Guidance

Featured image for "10 Entry-Level Jobs in Real Estate Without a License"
Industries

10 Entry-Level Jobs in Real Estate Without a License

You can get paid work in real estate without a salesperson license, because large parts of the industry — leasing, property management support, transaction coordination, title, mortgage operations, marketing and research — are administrative or operational rather than brokerage. The roles below are ranked by how quickly an employer will hire someone with no industry history, and by how much the work teaches you if you later want a license, a management track or a commercial seat.

Marisol Andrade · 13 min read

Featured image for "12 Jobs for People Who Like Helping Others Without Being a Nurse"
Industries

12 Jobs for People Who Like Helping Others Without Being a Nurse

If you want work where you spend the day with people who need something from you, nursing is one route out of many. The roles below sit in clinics, schools, ambulances, shelters, pharmacies and people's homes, and most are entered through a certificate, an associate degree or employer-paid training rather than a nursing program.

Wei Chen · 12 min read

Featured image for "How to Become a CDL Truck Driver (Steps, Skills and Pay)"
Industries

How to Become a CDL Truck Driver (Steps, Skills and Pay)

To become a CDL truck driver you need a commercial learner's permit, federally required entry-level driver training from a provider on the FMCSA Training Provider Registry, a DOT medical card, and a passing score on the CDL knowledge and skills tests at your state licensing agency. Most people go from first permit test to licensed and hired within two to six months.

Daniel Ortiz · 13 min read

Featured image for "How to Switch From Nursing to a Non-Clinical Career"
Industries

How to Switch From Nursing to a Non-Clinical Career

Most nurses who move into non-clinical work do it by adding one credential or one project to the experience they already have, then applying to roles that still need clinical judgment — documentation, informatics, quality, research, utilization review. The transition usually takes six to eighteen months of part-time preparation while you keep working, and it often starts with a committee seat or a super-user role inside your current employer rather than with a new degree.

Sofia Bauer · 15 min read