10 Signs a Company Is Hiring on Skills, Not Degrees

From how a posting is worded to who runs the interview, these are the clues that an employer will judge what you can do rather than where you studied.

By Nadia Hassan · Published · Updated · 13 min read

Featured image for "10 Signs a Company Is Hiring on Skills, Not Degrees"

A company that hires on skills leaves evidence you can see before you apply: how the posting describes requirements, what the application form asks for, whether there is a work sample, and who sits in the interview room. This guide ranks ten of those signs by how reliably they predict a real skills-based process, explains how to check each one in minutes, and shows how to use what you find in your application.

Skills-first hiring is not a niche experiment. Assessing skills rather than job titles expands employers' talent pools by nearly 10 times on average across the industries studied (LinkedIn Economic Graph, 2023), and the increase is larger for candidates without a bachelor's degree than for those with one (LinkedIn Economic Graph, 2023).

How we chose this list

The ranking criterion is simple: how hard the sign is to fake, and how much of it you can verify from outside before you spend time on an application.

A line in a job ad saying "degree or equivalent experience" costs an employer nothing. Building a structured work sample into the process, training interviewers to score against a rubric, or removing the education field from an application form all cost time and money. Signs near the top of this list are ones an employer has to actually build. Signs near the bottom are real but weaker on their own, because they can appear in a posting while the screening behind it still filters on credentials.

The list also leans on where skills-first hiring is demonstrably happening, so you know where to look. Public sector employers are a clear example: Maryland was the first state to drop degree requirements for most government jobs, a policy several other states have since adopted (BestColleges, undated), and Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro signed an executive order on his first full day in office removing the four-year degree requirement for a majority of state government jobs and directing agencies to emphasize skills and experience instead (National Governors Association, 2023). Opportunity@Work's STARs Public Sector Hub release refers to 16 states announcing plans to remove degrees from job postings since Maryland began in spring 2022 (Opportunity@Work, undated).

Nothing here guarantees you an offer. These signs tell you where your application has a fair chance of being read on its merits, which is a different and more useful thing.

The list at a glance

#SignHow to check itRough time
1A paid or structured work sample in the processRead the "what to expect" or "our process" section of the posting; ask the recruiter to list the stages5-10 minutes
2The application form has no education field, or makes it optionalStart the application and look at the required fields before submitting10-15 minutes
3Requirements written as tasks and tools, not as years and degreesCompare the posting's bullet list against the task list for that occupation on O*NET OnLine15-20 minutes
4A published competency framework or job architectureSearch the careers site and any public employee handbook for "competencies" or "levels"10-20 minutes
5An explicit "degree or equivalent experience" clause that names what countsRead the requirements section twice; note whether "equivalent" is defined5 minutes
6Public policy or commitment to skills-based hiringCheck the employer's newsroom, and for public sector roles the state's executive orders15-30 minutes
7Current staff with non-traditional backgrounds in the same roleScan profiles of people in that job title at that employer20-40 minutes
8Apprenticeships, returnships or internal mobility programmesLook for a separate "programmes" or "early careers" page on the careers site10-20 minutes
9Interviews that ask for examples and score them against a rubricAsk the recruiter directly how interviews are scored5 minutes plus a reply
10Certifications and portfolios named as acceptable evidenceLook for named credentials, licences or portfolio links in the requirements5-10 minutes
—Signs that look skills-first but aren'tRead the detail section below before you rely on any single clue10 minutes

Each item in detail

1. A paid or structured work sample in the process

This is the strongest sign, because it is the most expensive to build. The employer gives every candidate the same realistic task — a short writing exercise, a data clean-up, a mock service call, a trade test, a teaching demo — and scores the output against a fixed standard.

Check it by reading the "our hiring process" section of the posting or careers site, then confirming with the recruiter in your first call. Expect the check to take 5-10 minutes. Good signs: a stated time limit, a stated scoring method, and pay or a gift for anything over about two hours.

Use it by asking for the brief early and clearing your calendar. In the interview, walk through your reasoning rather than just the answer: "I assumed [constraint] because [reason], so I prioritised [task]."

2. The application form has no education field, or makes it optional

What a company asks for is what it screens on. If the applicant tracking system does not require a school, a graduation year or a GPA, nobody downstream can sort by it.

Check it by starting the application and reading every required field before you submit — 10-15 minutes. Note whether the form asks you to self-rate skills, upload a portfolio, or answer screening questions about tools and tasks.

Use it by putting your strongest evidence where the form actually looks: the skills section, the portfolio link, the screening answers. Do not hide a credential you hold, but lead with what you can do.

3. Requirements written as tasks and tools, not as years and degrees

A skills-first posting says "reconcile monthly accounts in [software]" rather than "3-5 years in a finance function, bachelor's required." The giveaway is that you could score yourself against each line.

Check it by pulling up the occupation on ONET OnLine, which lets you search occupations by technology skills and software and provides detailed reports on requirements, worker characteristics and training for over 900 occupations (ONET OnLine, U.S. Department of Labor, undated). Set the posting next to the O*NET task list for 15-20 minutes and see how closely they match.

Use it by mirroring the posting's own task language in your resume bullets, with a number or an outcome attached to each.

4. A published competency framework or job architecture

Some employers publish the levels they hire into and the behaviours expected at each one. This matters because it means the interview has a reference document behind it rather than a hiring manager's instinct.

Check it by searching the careers site, any public employee handbook, and for government roles the published classification specs — 10-20 minutes.

Ask the recruiter

"Is there a published competency framework or level description for [role]? I'd like to prepare examples that map to it."

Use it by picking two or three competencies and preparing a specific example for each.

5. A "degree or equivalent experience" clause that defines the equivalent

The clause itself is common. What separates a real signal from boilerplate is whether the posting says what counts — "four years of relevant experience, an apprenticeship, or a recognised certification."

Check it in five minutes by reading the requirements section twice. If "equivalent" is undefined, treat it as weak evidence and look for signs 1-4.

Use it by stating your equivalence plainly in the first lines of your application: "[X] years doing [task] in [setting], plus [credential]."

6. Public policy or a stated commitment to skills-based hiring

Some employers have said so on the record, and the public sector is the clearest case. North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper signed an executive order removing degree requirements for many state jobs and directing that related experience be considered instead (State Science & Technology Institute, undated). At federal level, the Chance to Compete Act, passed by the U.S. House, seeks to replace degree-based hiring with skills- and competency-based hiring in the civil service (Public Sector HR Association, undated). The sector is large: the Tear the Paper Ceiling campaign states that the public sector employs over 15 percent of the U.S. labor force and that governments are struggling to fill open roles (Opportunity@Work, undated).

Check it in 15-30 minutes: the employer's newsroom for private companies, the governor's office or state HR site for state jobs. Rules differ by state, so check the state you are applying in rather than assuming.

Use it by applying through the route the policy created, and by referencing the standard the employer has set for itself.

7. Current staff with non-traditional backgrounds in the same role

Policy is a claim; people are proof. If the team already contains former military, bootcamp graduates, internal promotions from support roles, or people who changed sector, the manager has hired that way before.

Check it by scanning public profiles of people holding that job title at that employer — 20-40 minutes. Look at the role they held immediately before.

Message to someone in the role

"I'm applying for [role] at [employer] and came from [background] rather than a [field] degree. Would you have ten minutes to tell me what the interview actually tested?"

Use it by naming the parallel in your cover note: you are not asking for an exception, you are following a path the team has already taken.

8. Apprenticeships, returnships or visible internal mobility

Employers who train people are employers who believe skills can be built. Registered apprenticeships, returnships for people with career breaks, and job postings open to internal applicants without the usual prerequisites all point the same way.

Check it by looking for a separate programmes page on the careers site, and for apprenticeship listings in your state's workforce agency pages — 10-20 minutes.

Use it by applying to the programme as well as the open role. Entry routes often have earlier deadlines and different assessors.

9. Interviews that ask for worked examples and score them

Structured interviews ask every candidate the same questions and score answers against agreed criteria. Unstructured ones drift toward where you studied and who you know.

Check it by asking the recruiter, in one line, how interviews are scored and whether the questions are the same for every candidate. Reply times vary; the ask takes five minutes.

Use it by answering in situation-action-result form, with the result quantified: "[Problem], I did [action] using [tool], and [measurable outcome] within [timeframe]."

10. Named certifications, licences and portfolios as acceptable evidence

When a posting names the specific credential, licence or portfolio it will accept, it has defined a route in that does not run through a campus. Licensing requirements vary by state, so confirm what your state requires before you pay for anything.

Check it in 5-10 minutes by listing every credential named in the posting, then checking the issuing body's own site for current requirements and costs.

Use it by putting the credential, issuer and date at the top of your resume, and by linking a portfolio that shows finished work rather than coursework.

Four things that look skills-first but aren't

This is where candidates lose time.

  • "Degree preferred" with a hard filter behind it. The posting is soft; the screening question is not. If the application form requires a graduation year, assume someone can sort by it.
  • A long unpaid take-home. A six-hour exercise with no feedback and no pay is not an assessment, it is free work. Ask what it is scored against and how long it should take.
  • A skills page with no skills process. Marketing copy about "potential over pedigree" alongside a four-round interview that never asks you to do the job.
  • One recruiter, not one employer. A skills-first recruiter at a credential-first company cannot change the hiring manager's shortlist.

The honest downside: even where the policy is genuine, skills-first hiring usually means more assessment, not less. You may do a work sample, a structured interview and a reference check for a role that would once have been handed to a graduate on paper. Budget the hours, and withdraw from processes that will not tell you how you are being scored.

Where to start

Career stageCheck these signs firstWhy
No degree, first job1 (work sample), 2 (no education field), 8 (apprenticeships)These remove the filter entirely rather than asking for an exception. Skills-first hiring increases candidate pools for Gen Z workers by over 10 times (LinkedIn Economic Graph, 2023)
Career changer with 5+ years elsewhere3 (task-based requirements), 5 (defined equivalence), 7 (staff with similar backgrounds)Your case rests on transferable tasks, so look for employers who have written requirements as tasks. Pools for Gen X and Millennial workers rise 8.5 and 9 times under skills-first hiring (LinkedIn Economic Graph, 2023)
Self-taught or bootcamp-trained1 (work sample), 10 (portfolios and certifications), 4 (competency framework)You can prove the work directly; find employers who will look at it
Returning after a break8 (returnships), 9 (structured interviews), 2 (application form)Structure protects you from gap-based assumptions
Entering a field where you're underrepresented1, 4, 9Structured, rubric-scored processes reduce the room for assumption. In jobs where women are underrepresented, skills-first hiring increases the proportion of women in candidate pools more than it does for men (LinkedIn Economic Graph, 2023)
Targeting stable, high-volume employers6 (public policy), 8 (apprenticeships)State and federal reform is where the clearest commitments are on record

If you want a starting point for which occupations to target at all, CareerOneStop's Skills Matcher lets you rate your level on a set of key workplace skills and returns occupations that match those ratings (CareerOneStop, U.S. Department of Labor, undated). For pay ranges and outlook in any occupation you shortlist, check the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook for your occupation and your metro area, since pay varies by employer, state and shift.

Frequently asked questions

Which sign should I check first?

Check the application form. Open the posting, start the application, and look at which fields are mandatory before you type anything. If education is required and there is no place to attach a portfolio or describe equivalent experience, the rest of the signals matter less — whatever the posting says, the form is what the screening system reads. It takes ten minutes and it tells you whether to invest another two hours.

How long does it take to check all ten signs for one employer?

Roughly 60-90 minutes for a thorough check, and about 20 minutes for a quick one covering signs 1, 2, 3 and 5. The spread depends on how much the employer publishes. Public sector employers often publish classification specs, executive orders and process descriptions, so checking is fast. Small private employers may publish almost nothing, in which case one email to the recruiter asking for the stages of the process and how interviews are scored replaces most of the research.

How do I prove skills I learned outside a classroom?

Lead with artefacts and outcomes. Put three to five pieces of finished work somewhere a stranger can open in one click, write each resume bullet as task plus tool plus result, and name any certification with its issuing body and date. In interviews, answer with a specific situation, the action you took, and a measurable result. Opportunity@Work describes candidates who are Skilled Through Alternative Routes rather than a bachelor's degree as STARs, and says more than 75 million such skilled workers are overlooked for lacking a degree (Opportunity@Work, undated) — the task is making your skills legible, not arguing about credentials.

Are there whole occupations where degrees aren't the entry route?

Yes. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics classifies a group of occupations as not typically needing any formal educational credential for entry, as part of its 2023-33 employment projections by education level (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024). Use O*NET OnLine to see the tasks, tools and training routes for specific occupations, and the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook to see typical entry requirements and outlook. Licensing still varies by state, so confirm your state's rules before committing to a route.

Sources

  1. LinkedIn Economic Graph — Skills-First: Reimagining the Labor Market and Breaking Down Barriers (2023)
  2. O*NET OnLine (U.S. Department of Labor / Employment and Training Administration) — O*NET OnLine Help: Technology Skills Search

More in Jobs News & Market Trends

Featured image for "How to Keep Your Job Search Moving During a Government Shutdown"
News

How to Keep Your Job Search Moving During a Government Shutdown

A shutdown stops a lot of federal hiring, but it does not stop the rest of the labor market. The useful moves are narrow and concrete: confirm whether you are furloughed or excepted, file for unemployment in the right state if you qualify, convert your federal resume into something a private employer can read, and keep talking to people who are still hiring.

James O'Connor · 14 min read

Featured image for "Best Careers for Workers Affected by Federal Layoffs"
News

Best Careers for Workers Affected by Federal Layoffs

If a federal layoff, RIF or deferred-resignation offer has ended your job, the strongest next moves are the ones that reuse what you already did: contract and grants administration, compliance and risk, program and project management, budget and data analysis, and safety or quality inspection. Those skills move into state and local government, universities, hospitals, nonprofits, federal contractors and regulated private employers without starting from zero.

Marisol Andrade · 13 min read

Featured image for "How to Switch From a Declining Industry to a Growing One"
News

How to Switch From a Declining Industry to a Growing One

Switching from a declining industry to a growing one works best when you treat it as three separate problems: picking a target role that actually hires people like you, closing the smallest possible skills gap, and surviving the pay dip in between. Most people who do it well move sideways into an adjacent occupation rather than starting from zero, and the move takes somewhere between six and eighteen months from first research call to first paycheck in the new field.

Theo Lindqvist · 14 min read

Featured image for "How Long Does It Take to Become a Union Apprentice?"
News

How Long Does It Take to Become a Union Apprentice?

Expect roughly three months to two years between your first application and your first day on the job, then another three to five years of paid work and classroom hours before you finish the program. The application side is the unpredictable part — many locals open applications only once or twice a year, rank everyone who tests and interviews, and call names off that list as contractors need people.

Desmond Okafor · 12 min read